Today's most viewed
Controversy as eco-friendly homes unveiled
 |
| A Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust artist's impression of what homes on the Derwenthorpe estate could look like |
THIS is what the eco-friendly homes in a massive housing development on the outskirts of York could look like - and plans have been submitted to build three of them in the city.
The Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust (JRHT), which is to build the 540-home Derwenthorpe model village on land at Osbaldwick, has applied to City of York Council to build three prototype properties in New Earswick.
Under the two applications, the trust would build two detached homes on land to the west of Acacia Avenue, and one three-storey detached home on land between Chestnut Grove and Hawthorn Terrace South.
In a statement, Richards Partington Architects said the prototypes would allow for the testing of innovative construction methods which were required in order to achieve the high environmental performance targets that have been set for the Derwenthorpe site.
They said it was fitting the homes should be located in New Earswick because they had a character that was in keeping with the rest of the village.
The architects said that, in terms of environmental sustainability, the homes were underpinned by three key principles: maximising the amount of energy a house can get from its external environment, high levels of thermal insulation, and good levels of air-tightness with controlled ventilation.
They said one of the key elements of the homes was that they would have a living space designed to benefit from the heating potential of winter sunshine. Meanwhile, local residents have objected to both planning applications.
Lindsey Houston, of Ivy Place, whose homes surround the green where the three-storey detached home would be built, has been nominated as spokeswoman for the residents of Ivy Place and Station Avenue.
She said: "The house doesn't really relate to the existing two-storey terraced cottage style of the surrounding housing.
"Privacy of many of the existing residents will be compromised by this construction - it's going to be a three-storey dwelling overlooking the existing two-storey houses."
Jane Clarkson, of Willow Bank, said two of the homes would overlook where she lived.
She said: "The ethos of Joseph Rowntree was to build a village for his workers providing them with quality of life, therefore the green areas are so important and shouldn't be built on."
Nigel Ingram, director of development and property services at JRHT, said: "The intention of these planning applications was for the trust to get views on our proposals from residents, the parish council and City of York Council planners during their period of statutory consultation.
"We are seriously considering these views and will be responding within the next few days.
"The image used in the design and access statements - part of the planning applications - was included for illustrative purposes only. The colour and materials shown in the image would not necessarily be those that would be used."
1:11pm Friday 9th May 2008
Print 
Email this
CommentPosted by: voiceoreason, york on 1:54pm Fri 9 May 08
countdown to nimby comments has begun ............
countdown to nimby comments has begun ............
Posted by: Jason on 2:04pm Fri 9 May 08
i think they look excellent. Much better than some of the cr*p built around York in the last 10 years.
i think they look excellent. Much better than some of the cr*p built around York in the last 10 years.
Posted by: bernard on 2:23pm Fri 9 May 08
Look alot nicer than the three bedroom semi's that are all over Osbaldwick (including ours).
Look alot nicer than the three bedroom semi's that are all over Osbaldwick (including ours).
Posted by: X, At Work on 2:34pm Fri 9 May 08
haven't they already built one of these near Clifton bridge?
It looks well out of place, but if they are starting a new estate it will look a lot better.
My house is eco friendly now... Iv'e turned the heating off (don't tell the wife)
haven't they already built one of these near Clifton bridge?
It looks well out of place, but if they are starting a new estate it will look a lot better.
My house is eco friendly now... Iv'e turned the heating off (don't tell the wife)
Posted by: Chumpy69, York on 2:51pm Fri 9 May 08
The one near Clifton bridge does look out of place but i agree a new estate will look really smart.
And im with you on the heating lol..although im going to be in trouble because this is the wifes user name.
GULP!!!
The one near Clifton bridge does look out of place but i agree a new estate will look really smart.
And im with you on the heating lol..although im going to be in trouble because this is the wifes user name.
GULP!!!
Posted by: Cruddass is a muppett on 3:00pm Fri 9 May 08
That man in the picture - I hate his trousers. I think they cause more controversy than the house.
That man in the picture - I hate his trousers. I think they cause more controversy than the house.
Posted by: GoodramgateTerrier, York on 3:32pm Fri 9 May 08
I can hear window cleaners across the city running to apply for that estate on there route!
I can hear window cleaners across the city running to apply for that estate on there route!
Posted by: misskittie, York on 4:52pm Fri 9 May 08
the houses look great but I agree that a whole estate will look better than three bizarre additions to New Earswick. Have JRF not got enough land at Derwenthorpe that they need to use New Earswick as a testing ground?
the houses look great but I agree that a whole estate will look better than three bizarre additions to New Earswick. Have JRF not got enough land at Derwenthorpe that they need to use New Earswick as a testing ground?
Posted by: BL on 5:07pm Fri 9 May 08
Maybe they're just houses for really tall people?
Maybe they're just houses for really tall people?
Posted by: Lamplighter on 5:23pm Fri 9 May 08
[quote]She said: "The ethos of Joseph Rowntree was to build a village for his workers providing them with quality of life,[/quote] How many of his workers live there now? Answer: none, his ancestors sold out his legacy.
She said: "The ethos of Joseph Rowntree was to build a village for his workers providing them with quality of life,
How many of his workers live there now? Answer: none, his ancestors sold out his legacy.
Posted by: Lamplighter on 5:24pm Fri 9 May 08
Of course you've all spotted the deliberate mistake in my last post! <Grin>
Of course you've all spotted the deliberate mistake in my last post! <Grin>
Posted by: MichaelRutherford, York on 5:39pm Fri 9 May 08
I don't think that unusual buildings are necessarily a bad thing, but how can a building with such large areas of glass be environmentally friendly?
I don't think that unusual buildings are necessarily a bad thing, but how can a building with such large areas of glass be environmentally friendly?
Posted by: Guy Fawkes, Bootham on 5:57pm Fri 9 May 08
I like the look of the house. But presumably they'd have to be spaced quite widely apart, because otherwise the ones next door would block out the natural light needed to keep the buildings warm.
I like the look of the house. But presumably they'd have to be spaced quite widely apart, because otherwise the ones next door would block out the natural light needed to keep the buildings warm.
Posted by: Oscar, York on 7:28am Sat 10 May 08
We'll all be eco friendly soon, we won't be able to afford gas or electricity.
We'll all be eco friendly soon, we won't be able to afford gas or electricity.
Posted by: the Butler, Cowichan Bay B.C Canada on 6:50pm Sat 10 May 08
Where are the solar panels?.There is way too much glass, Is there thermal storage below the foundation?
It also looks as though heavey falls of snow are to be expected looking at the roof pitch...
Where are the solar panels?.There is way too much glass, Is there thermal storage below the foundation?
It also looks as though heavey falls of snow are to be expected looking at the roof pitch...
Posted by: oli4uk, York on 10:07am Mon 12 May 08
I was beaten to the crunch point. An Eco Friendly house should have the minimum amount of glass possible. This seems to be just another case of some designer architect wanting to make his mark.
I was beaten to the crunch point. An Eco Friendly house should have the minimum amount of glass possible. This seems to be just another case of some designer architect wanting to make his mark.
What are these links for?
If you liked this article and would like to share it with others on the web who might be searching for good content we've made it easy for you to do it.
At the bottom of all articles, you'll see links to six sites. These sites - commonly called 'social bookmark' or 'social news' sites - have large communities of web users who share and rate interesting, useful and fun things on the web.
Clicking the links will automatically add the address of the story you are reading to one of these sites, letting you share it with others. Each site will ask you to register to share stories. Registration is free and once a member, you can store, recommend and search for stories that interest you.
More on Digg
More on del.icio.us
More on Furl
More on reddit
More on NowPublic/
More on Yahoo!